Your Pie Pizza

A Hidden Gem in Loganville I stumbled upon this spot and was genuinely blown away. From the moment I walked in, the staff greeted me with warmth and professionalism that set the tone for an exceptional experience. The restaurant was spotless, and the service was not only efficient but incredibly friendly—something that’s becoming rare these days. Now let’s talk about the food: outstanding. I’ve tried several locations of Your Pie, and none come close to the quality and care I experienced here. The flavors were bold, fresh, and perfectly balanced. This Loganville location truly sets the standard for what a chain restaurant should aspire to be.

I ordered 5 pizzas and 1 kids pasta and some Texas Pete wings online for delivery, never again! When I received the order the pizzas were soggy and barely baked. The wings were barely cooked and I specifically added notes on the wing order about cooking well done but not burnt, instead they were barely cooked and extremely soggy when I received them. Also all of the pizza boxes were sticky, that’s nasty and shouldn’t have left the establishment like that. That is over $80 in the trash because this establishment didn’t care enough to make my family quality food. Never again will I spend money here.

Perfect in every way! I ordered The Nat and mixed the basil sauce with marinara. Pizza is just the right size with healthy options to choose from. The customer service was also perfect! I watched not only how they interacted with us, the customers to make sure everything we ordered was made perfect, but also how the employees worked as a team. I will definitely be back often❤️

I come here often and usually don’t have any issues. I have a gluten allergy so I always specify that when ordering online. They prepare my pizza in the back and luckily I haven’t got sick from them. That’s why I keep going back. But today when I ordered my pizza this is what it looked like. I didn’t ask for extra toppings whatsoever. I even asked for it well done on the special instructions. I ordered the classic lineage pizza. I was appalled when I reached my destination and opened the box to find this. The amount of toppings!! The toppings were ice cold. It was inedible. The cheese was not even fully melted. I called and they fixed the situation with no problem. But I wanted to post this because more training might need to be done for employees to know correct procedures and possibly figuring out exactly how long to cook pizzas, especially gluten free pizzas.

We love this location. Parking is always available and easy. There is plenty of seating and with the high ceilings, it never feels too crowded. The food is great and our children love going for pizza and gelato!